As demand for digital infrastructure, artificial intelligence, and cloud computing accelerates, municipalities across the country are experiencing increased interest in data center development. These facilities are often presented as essential infrastructure with economic upside, yet the political and regulatory environment surrounding data centers has become increasingly active and, in some communities, contentious. As community concerns grow, municipalities may face heightened exposure to zoning disputes, administrative appeals, and litigation alleging procedural deficiencies or adverse community impacts. Regardless of where a municipality ultimately lands on any specific proposal, it is important for municipal leaders to understand how this evolving environment may intersect with municipal risk exposure and property and liability insurance considerations.
Property, Infrastructure, and Environmental Risk Considerations
From a property and infrastructure standpoint, data centers present unique risk characteristics. Hyperscale facilities require extraordinary levels of electrical capacity, water for cooling, and redundant systems, often triggering infrastructure upgrades that intersect with municipal utilities, rights‑of‑way, and public property. Municipal involvement in approving, facilitating, or maintaining supporting infrastructure may create questions around responsibility for downstream impacts, particularly where residential ratepayers experience increased utility costs or service disruptions.
In addition, water use has emerged as a particularly sensitive issue. Reporting in Pennsylvania and other states has documented community concerns about groundwater depletion, stressed municipal water systems, and accountability when private wells or public supplies are impacted. From a risk perspective, these conditions can give rise to claims alleging property damage, nuisance, or failure to adequately assess environmental impact. Municipal property coverage and environmental liability exposures should be reviewed carefully where water‑intensive development is contemplated.
Noise, air emissions, and backup power generation are additional factors influencing municipal liability considerations. Data centers commonly rely on large cooling systems and diesel generators, which have prompted complaints related to constant low‑frequency noise and air quality, particularly in communities already burdened by industrial activity. Allegations of diminished property values, adverse health effects, or inequitable siting decisions may implicate general liability, public officials’ liability, and, in some cases, civil rights or environmental justice claims.
Planning Ahead from a Risk Management Perspective
In the current environment, municipal risk associated with data centers is less about politics and more about preparedness. Multiple policy organizations and academic sources have stated that data centers often deliver limited long‑term employment benefits while shifting infrastructure and environmental burdens to local communities. That imbalance can translate into sustained exposure long after construction is complete.
From an insurance perspective, municipalities may wish to:
- Re‑evaluate zoning requirements where data centers may be proposed, and document all research findings
- Ensure your zoning includes a "Decommissioning Clause." i.e. a plan for how the building will be repurposed or demolished if it sits vacant for more than 24 months
- Clarify zoning dispute and appeal processes
- Ensure a communication framework is set up with local infrastructure to discuss the consumption impact of power grid, water, fiber optic, transportation and site access.
- Continue to monitor federal guidelines and state-level legislative trends related to data centers
- Decisions to approve, develop, or decline a data center project can have liability implications.
- General Liability and Public Officials & Employees Liability coverage may be implicated depending on the nature of the claims and activities involved.
- Certain risks such as environmental exposures, cyber‑related incidents, and contract‑specific liabilities may be limited or excluded under the Trust’s coverage.
- Coordinate early with the Trust and your legal counsel when considering a data center project to discuss potential risk considerations and how coverage may respond
- Remember: The Trust provides contractual review of indemnification and insurance provisions in your agreements as a value-added service!
Municipalities that approach these projects with a clear understanding of risk allocation will be better positioned to protect public assets, manage claims exposure, and maintain trust with their communities.
Understanding Your Coverage
As municipalities across the region evaluate proposals to build data centers, it is important to understand how those decisions can intersect with your existing liability coverage. If a municipality elects to move forward with a data center project, certain parts of the Delaware Valley Property and Liability Trust’s coverage may be implicated during the planning, construction, and operational phases. For example:
-
Your General Liability coverage generally covers claims alleging bodily injury or property damage arising out of an occurrence, such as construction‑related incidents, premises liability claims, or allegations involving municipal operations connected to the site.
-
Your Public Officials and Employees Liability coverage generally covers claims alleging wrongful acts in zoning, land use, permitting, or other discretionary decision‑making tied to the approval or oversight of a data center project. These coverages generally include the Trust’s duty to defend, subject to the applicable limits, terms, and exclusions set forth in the Coverage Document.
-
However, environmental‑related claims, including pollution conditions or PFAS‑related allegations, are subject to broad exclusions
-
Cyber‑related losses are addressed only in limited circumstances and often on a contingent basis.
-
If a municipality decides not to proceed with a data center, allegations of improper denial, failure to approve, or other governmental action may arise, potentially implicating Public Officials Liability coverage.
As always, coverage is fact‑specific and subject to the full terms, exclusions, and conditions of the Trust’s coverage. Members are encouraged to engage with the Trust early when considering large‑scale development projects so that risk considerations and coverage implications can be evaluated proactively.
Key Takeaways
- Decisions to approve, develop, or decline a data center project can have liability implications.
- General Liability and Public Officials & Employees Liability coverage may be implicated depending on the nature of the claims and activities involved.
- Certain risks such as environmental exposures, cyber‑related incidents, and contract‑specific liabilities may be limited or excluded under the Trust’s coverage.
- Coordinate early with the Trust and your legal counsel when considering a data center project to discuss potential risk considerations and how coverage may respond
- Remember: The Trust provides contractual review of indemnification and insurance provisions in your agreements as a value-added service!
As always, feel free to contact Mark Harris at mharris@dvtrusts.com or your lead risk control consultant with any questions or concerns.